Protective Put Strategy for Energy Products at NSE

  • Kedia Advisory
  • Commodities News
Protective Put Strategy for Energy Products at NSE
Credit: © Reuters.

The Protective Put Strategy is a risk management approach widely employed in the energy products market at the National Stock Exchange (NSE). In the dynamic and often volatile energy sector, investors and traders seek strategies to protect their positions from adverse price movements. The Protective Put Strategy, also known as the "married put" or "portfolio insurance," offers a powerful tool to achieve this objective. This strategy involves purchasing a put option for each unit of the underlying energy product held in the portfolio. In the context of the NSE, where energy products such as crude oil and natural gas are actively traded, the Protective Put Strategy allows market participants to mitigate downside risk associated with price fluctuations in these commodities. The put option provides the holder with the right, but not the obligation, to sell the underlying asset at a predetermined price, known as the strike price, within a specified time frame. By employing the Protective Put Strategy, investors in the energy market can establish a floor for potential losses, safeguarding their portfolios against adverse market conditions. This is particularly valuable in the energy sector, where geopolitical events, supply-demand dynamics, and macroeconomic factors can lead to sudden and significant price swings. The strategy is conducive to managing risk while allowing participants to maintain exposure to potential upside movements in the energy market. In the subsequent sections of this course, we will delve deeper into the mechanics of the Protective Put Strategy, exploring its application in the context of energy products traded on the NSE. Through comprehensive analysis, case studies, and practical exercises, participants will gain a nuanced understanding of how this strategy can enhance risk management in the dynamic and challenging landscape of energy commodity trading.

Advantages of the Protective Put Strategy for Energy Products:

The Protective Put Strategy for energy products at the National Stock Exchange (NSE) offers several advantages to investors and traders seeking to navigate the complexities of the energy market while managing risk effectively:

Downside Protection: The primary advantage of the Protective Put Strategy is its ability to provide downside protection. By purchasing put options, investors can establish a predetermined selling price for their energy products. This safeguards their portfolio from potential losses in the event of adverse price movements in the energy market.

Flexibility in Risk Management: The strategy is highly flexible and adaptable to different risk appetites. Investors can choose varying strike prices and expiration dates for the put options based on their risk tolerance and market outlook. This flexibility allows for customization according to individual risk management preferences.

Maintains Upside Potential: While the Protective Put Strategy protects against downside risk, it still allows investors to participate in potential upside movements in the energy market. If the market experiences favourable price trends, investors can benefit from the unhindered appreciation of their underlying energy assets.

Insurance Against Volatility: The energy market is known for its volatility, influenced by geopolitical events, supply and demand dynamics, and global economic conditions. The Protective Put Strategy acts as insurance, mitigating the impact of sudden and unpredictable price swings, which are common in the energy sector.

Strategic Portfolio Management: Integrating the Protective Put Strategy into a portfolio of energy products enables strategic risk management. It provides a structured approach to protecting the overall value of the portfolio, particularly in times of heightened uncertainty or market turbulence.

Peace of Mind for Investors: Knowing that a protective put is in place can provide peace of mind for investors, allowing them to stay invested in the energy market without constant concern about potential downturns. This psychological reassurance can contribute to more informed decision-making and disciplined investment strategies.

When to Use Protective Put Strategy

The Protective Put Strategy for energy products at the National Stock Exchange (NSE) is particularly useful in various scenarios to manage risk and protect investment portfolios. Here are situations when investors may consider employing the Protective Put Strategy:

Anticipation of Market Volatility: If there are expectations of increased volatility in the energy market due to upcoming events, economic releases, or geopolitical developments, investors may choose to implement the Protective Put Strategy. This helps guard against sudden and adverse price movements.

Ahead of Known Risk Events: Before events that are known to impact the energy market, such as OPEC meetings, geopolitical tensions, or major economic announcements, investors may use the Protective Put Strategy to shield their positions from potential negative outcomes.

During Uncertain Economic Conditions: Economic uncertainty can significantly impact energy prices. When economic indicators suggest instability or when there's uncertainty about global economic conditions, investors may opt for the Protective Put Strategy to mitigate potential losses.

In the Face of Geopolitical Risks: Geopolitical events, such as conflicts in oil-producing regions, can lead to sudden and sharp movements in energy prices. Investors concerned about the geopolitical landscape may employ the Protective Put Strategy to protect their positions.

Ahead of Earnings Releases: For companies in the energy sector, earnings releases can have a substantial impact on stock prices. Investors holding energy stocks may choose to implement the Protective Put Strategy before earnings announcements to manage potential downside risk.

As a General Risk Management Tool: Investors may use the Protective Put Strategy as a standard risk management tool in their overall investment strategy. It can be a proactive approach to protect against unforeseen market developments and maintain a level of stability in the portfolio.

For Long-Term Holdings: Investors with long-term positions in energy products may use the Protective Put Strategy to safeguard their investments over an extended period. This is especially relevant when holding energy assets through various market cycles.

As a Portfolio Hedge: The Protective Put Strategy can be employed as part of a broader portfolio hedging strategy. By protecting the energy component of a diversified portfolio, investors can enhance the overall risk-adjusted return of their investment holdings.

Steps for Execution of Protective Put Strategy

Executing the Protective Put Strategy for energy products at the National Stock Exchange (NSE) involves several steps. Here's a guide on how to execute this strategy:

Understand the Market Environment: Assess the current and anticipated market conditions for energy products. Analyse factors such as geopolitical events, economic indicators, and supply-demand dynamics that could impact energy prices.

Identify the Underlying Energy Asset: Choose the specific energy product or stock for which you want to implement the Protective Put Strategy.

Determine the Holding Size: Decide on the quantity or size of the energy asset you want to protect using the Protective Put Strategy. This decision is influenced by your existing portfolio and risk tolerance.

Select the Appropriate Put Option: Choose a put option with a strike price and expiration date that aligns with your risk management goals. Consider the cost of the put option and its premium in relation to your overall investment strategy.

Calculate the Total Cost: Determine the total cost of purchasing the put options by multiplying the number of contracts by the cost per contract.

Place the Protective Put Order: Use your brokerage platform to place an order to buy the selected put option(s). Specify the number of contracts and the relevant details (strike price, expiration date).

Monitor the Portfolio: Regularly monitor the market and any changes in the factors affecting the energy sector. Keep track of the performance of the underlying energy asset and the put option.

Evaluate Adjustments: Assess the need for adjustments to the Protective Put Strategy based on market developments. Consider rolling the put option if the expiration date is approaching and you want to maintain protection.

Decide on Strategy Continuation or Adjustment: Depending on market conditions, decide whether to continue with the Protective Put Strategy, adjust the strike price or expiration date, or let the strategy expire.

Review and Learn: After the Protective Put Strategy has been executed, review its effectiveness. Evaluate the impact on the portfolio during periods of market volatility and assess whether adjustments could have been made for better outcomes.

Stay Informed: Continuously stay informed about market trends, economic indicators, and geopolitical events that could affect the energy market. Be ready to adjust your strategy based on changing conditions.

Execute Exit Strategy: If the market conditions have improved and the need for protection decreases, consider executing an exit strategy for the Protective Put Strategy. This may involve selling the put option(s) to realize gains or minimize losses. Remember that the execution of the Protective Put Strategy requires a comprehensive understanding of the energy market, option pricing, and risk management principles. 

Actual Execution of Protective Put Strategy in Crude Oil

Let's consider a hypothetical scenario for the Protective Put Strategy in Crude Oil being traded at NSE. For simplicity, we'll use round numbers for the price of Crude Oil and the option premiums. Please note that actual market conditions may vary, and it's essential to use real-time data for accurate decision-making.

The assumptions for the Protective Put Strategy are as follows:

Current Crude Oil price at NSE: Rs. 6,100 per barrel

Number of barrels per contract: 100

Cost of one put option contract: Rs. 500

Strike price of the put option: Rs. 6,000 per barrel

Expiration date of the put option: 1 month from the current date

Now, let's consider the scenarios of price movement: Upward, Stable, and Downward.

1. Upward Price Movement: 

The table illustrates the effect of an upward price movement in Crude Oil on a hypothetical portfolio comprising a physical position and a corresponding put option. With the increase in Crude Oil price, a loss is incurred on the physical position, partially offset by the gain in the value of the put option. The upward price movement results in a loss of Rs. 6,500 on the physical position, reflecting the adverse impact of the rising market value of the commodity. However, the put option, serving as a risk management tool, experiences a gain in value amounting to Rs. 50,000. This increase in the put option's value helps counterbalance the loss on the physical position.

Despite the loss on the physical position, the appreciation in the put option's value limits the overall negative impact on the portfolio. The total portfolio value remains at Rs. 50,000. It's noteworthy that the put option has expired worthless, emphasizing the significance of its increased value in mitigating the effects of the upward price movement.

In summary, the strategic use of a put option in response to the rising Crude Oil price demonstrates the potential for options to act as a hedging mechanism, managing risk and providing a level of protection against adverse market conditions.

2. Stable Price Movement: The provided table illustrates a scenario involving a stable crude oil price and the impact on a portfolio comprising a physical position and a put option. In this case, the put option, which serves as a form of insurance against potential price declines, has expired worthless due to the stable crude oil price.

The physical position in crude oil, valued at Rs. 50,000, retains its original worth as the put option did not need to be exercised. The cost of the premium for the put option, amounting to Rs. 500, represents the loss incurred on the option. Consequently, the total portfolio value decreases from the initial Rs. 50,000 to Rs. 49,500, reflecting the expense of the put option premium.

This scenario highlights the trade-off involved in using options for risk management. While the stable crude oil price eliminates the need to exercise the put option, the cost of purchasing the option in the first place results in a reduction in the overall portfolio value. Traders and investors often employ options as a means of mitigating risk, and in cases of stable market conditions, the cost of the option premium serves as a form of insurance expense.

3. Downward Price Movement: In the given scenario, the crude oil price has experienced a decline, resulting in a loss in the physical position. However, this loss is mitigated to some extent by a corresponding gain in the value of the put option. The physical position registers a loss of Rs. 5,700. Simultaneously, the put option gains Rs. 300 in value, acting as a hedge against the declining oil prices.

As a result, the total portfolio value is Rs. 50,300, which reflects the combined impact of the physical position and the put option. The profit from the put option helps offset the losses incurred in the physical position, showcasing the risk management aspect of employing options in a portfolio. This strategy allows investors to protect themselves from adverse price movements and limit potential losses, thereby enhancing the overall resilience of the portfolio during market fluctuations.

In these scenarios, the Protective Put Strategy provides a level of protection against potential losses in a downward market while allowing participation in upside movements. Again, remember that actual market conditions and option pricing can vary, so it's essential to use real-time data and adapt calculations accordingly.

Drop an image here or Supported formats: *.jpg, *.png, *.gif up to 5mb

Error: File type not supported

Drop an image here or


Related Articles